Showing posts with label Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Show all posts

Friday, 10 July 2015

Response to Ayaan Hirsi Ali on Rapes in Muslim Country


Here Hirsi Ali attributes the attitudes of some Muslims to Islam itself. But we can hardly credit to Islam everything that Muslims do. Yet this is a mistake Hirsi Ali makes throughout her book. For example, when in a Muslim majority nation many women were raped, Hirsi Ali blamed this on Islam (p. 146). Thus she failed to see that in a case like this the fault is not with the faith, which forbids rape, but with the rapists for failing to follow the faith. 

From Dr Shabir Ally's review of Ayan Hirsi Ali's book


Reveal Muslim Scholars Views on Rape For All


 
Sheikh Hamza Yusuf and Imam Suhain Webb on rape and rapists

ISIS and 'Forced Sex' and 'Extreme Sex' Claims


Did Muslims or Zionists Send Death Threats to Jenny Tonge?





 
 

BOOK REVIEW: Heretic - by Ayaan Hirsi Ali | Dr. Shabir Ally

In a new book entitled, “Heretic – Why Islam Needs a Reformation Now,” author Ayan Hirsi Ali argues that religious reformation is the only way to end terrorism, sectarian warfare, and repression of women in the Muslim world. Dr. Shabir Ally discusses her call to reform Islam.




The book is not only a criticism of Islam but of religion more generally. For example, Ayaan Hirsi Ali states that there is no life after death, and that God is created by mankind and not the other way around (p. 44).

More specifically to Islam, she rejects the belief that God is the author of the Quran, and she rejects Muhammad (pbuh) as a moral guide (p. 44). For her reform project, she needs credibility. So, she tries to reposition herself as a heretic as distinct from her previous posture as an infidel. Why this new posture? The reason, she explains, is that when she squarely positioned herself as an apostate and an infidel she found herself being shunned by both Muslim and non-Muslim audiences (p.17). She is thus blatantly honest about this. And for her honesty she deserves credit, though we should not be naïve about her agenda. She recalls that when she wrote her previous book, Nomad, she had believed that Islam was beyond reformation, and that perhaps it would be best for Muslims to pick another god (p. 74). But her present distinction between infidel and heretic is merely semantic, for she maintains even in the present book that she remains outside of the faith, and that it is too late for her to embrace the faith again (p. 75)—although I would maintain that it is never too late.

THE TERM ‘REFORMATION’

The term ‘reformation’ in religious discourse refers primarily to the protestant reformation which began with Martin Luther’s protest against papal authority. In that sense it is fallacious to say that Islam needs this, since the majority of Muslims subscribe to nothing comparable to papal authority.

But the term has come to be used more widely in the sense of revisiting religious dogma in the light of modern knowledge. In this sense, it can apply to Islam. Some people use it to speak of going back to the original core of the faith. Others, such as Hirsi Ali, use it to speak of abandoning that original core.

But this is where Hirsi Ali trades on ambiguity, thus falling into one of the standard logical fallacies in argumentation. She is using the term to abandon the core of Islam while trying to gain acceptance as a sort of Martin Luther. But Luther was not abandoning the core of Christianity but only the papacy. He was attempting to recapture the core of Pauline Christianity.


Read all of Dr Shabir's review/response to Ayan Hirsi Ali's new book here:
http://www.quranspeaks.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Problems-with-Hirsi-Alis-book.pdf

Yasir Qadhi on Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Ayaan Hirsi Ali Exposed

Experience with Israeli Border Control

People converting to Islam

More about the Paraclete

Prophecies of the Messiah - Reza Aslan

Muslims give the most charity and have least sex outside of marriage!

Pastor learns about Hijab

Trend: Christians Leaving Christianity

British Muslims Protested to Defend Jesus p


Sharia Law against terrorism

Christians having dreams and converting to Islam


Learn about Islam

Email: yahyasnow@yahoo.co.uk

Sunday, 5 April 2015

Ayaan Hirsi Ali Exposed


History of fraud
 
Hirsi Ali’s highly suspect statistic is only the latest deception by one of the world’s most prominent opponents of Islam. While other anti-Muslim activists like Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller have marginalized themselves on the fringes of the far-right, Hirsi Ali remains a darling of the American mainstream media. In Heretic, a polemic recycling many of her past arguments against Islam, she calls for the emergence of a Muslim Martin Luther — the authoritarian 16th-century zealot who called for burning down the synagogues of Jews, whom he compared to a gangrenous disease.

With the book’s release, Hirsi Ali has been welcomed with open arms by the BBC, CNN’s Anderson Cooper, and a relatively accommodating Jon Stewart. ABC News has even run an excerpt from Heretic, while the New York Times Book Review hosted her for an interview filled with hardball questions about her favorite children’s books.
 
Hirsi Ali’s power to persuade lies in her dramatic personal story and the public persona she has constructed. She has marketed herself as a expert native informant who has emerged out of the dark heart of radical Islam and into the light of Western civilization. Her tale is an uplifting, comforting one that tells many Westerners what they want to hear about themselves and their perceived enemies. With anti-Muslim attitudes at their peak across Europe and the US, her sweeping critique of Islam as an endemically violent faith has enormous cachet. The only problem is that like her writings on Islam, much of what she has told the public about herself is questionable.
 
In May 2006, the Dutch television program Zembla thoroughly debunked the dramatic story Hirsi Ali had told to advance her career, concluding that Hirsi Ali had sold the Dutch public “a story full of obscurities.”
 
Born Ayaan Hirsi Magam, she migrated to the Netherlands in 1992, changed her name to Hirsi Ali, and lied to Dutch authorities about her past. Contrary to the story she told the government, she arrived in the Netherlands not from war-torn Somalia, but from Kenya, where she lived in a secure environment and under the protection of the United Nations, which funded her education at a well-regarded Muslim girls’ school. Though she told immigration authorities and the Dutch public she had fled from civil war in Somalia, she left that country before its war broke out. Indeed, she did not live through a war there or anywhere else. Thanks to her fabrications, Hirsi Ali received political asylum in just five weeks.
 
Hirsi Ali told astonished audiences on Dutch talk shows that her supposedly devout family had forced her to marry a draconian Muslim man, that she had not been present at her own wedding, and that her family had threatened to kill her for offending their religious honor. However, Zembla told a drastically different story. Hirsi Ali’s brother, aunt and former husband each testified that she had indeed been present at her wedding. It turned out that Hirsi Ali’s mother had sent her brother to a Christian school, not exactly an indication of Islamic fanaticism.
 
“Yeah, I made up the whole thing,” Hirsi Ali admitted on camera to a Zembla reporter who confronted her with her lies. “I said my name was Ayaan Hirsi Ali instead of Ayaan Hirsi Magan. I also said I was born in 1967 while I was actually born in 1969.”
 
Hirsi Ali’s claim of honor killing threats also appears to be empty; she remained in touch with her father and aunt after she left her husband. In fact, her husband even came to visit her in the Dutch refugee center where she lived after leaving him. Even though he had paid her way to Europe on the grounds that she would join him in Canada, Hirsi Ali’s husband consented to the divorce she sought. (Watch the full Zembla program on Hirsi Ali.)
 
Fabrications that toppled a government
 
In 2003, just a decade after gaining political asylum in the Netherlands, Hirsi Ali was elected to the Dutch parliament on the ticket of the People’s Party for Freedom and Democracy. VVD leadership knew that the story Hirsi Ali told on her immigration forms was a gigantic lie — she had told them as much — but covered up the fraud and even advanced it to propel her career.
 
“She’s witnessed five civil wars in her youth, and has fled with her family many times. She’s made of iron and steel,” the VVD’s Neelie-Smit Kroes said of Hirsi Ali at the time, reciting claims her party knew were false.
 
Taken from: http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/one_of_americas_most_prominent_islam_bashers_long_history_20150402

[QURAN MIRACLES] The Miracles of the Number 19 in Quran | Dr. Shabir Ally

ISIS Members Having Dreams of Jesus?

People having dreams and visions showing Jesus is not divine

Russell Brand Exposes Muslim Terrorism Percentage
 
 
 

Wednesday, 9 April 2014

Yasir Qadhi on Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Here's a respected Muslim scholar, Sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi, exposing Ayaan Hirsi Ali on his FaceBook:

Ayaan Hirsi Ali is clearly someone we strongly disagree with, and are frankly disgusted by (the way she has used her anti-Islamic rants to become rich and famous). She has called Islam a 'nihilistic faith' that is intrinsically backward and evil and prone to violence and terrorism and subjugation of women, etc.

So, clearly, we don't like her and are biased against her. However, I think that despite our prejudices, it is VERY safe and reasonable to say that she is not scholarly or academic in ANY sense of the term. Shrill, loud, attention-seeking, shallow, cacophonous, narcissist Islamphobe - all of these adjectives can be defended. But scholarly? Seriously, what has she done that demonstrates in ANY way that she is an academic capable of valuable research? Forget academics, what has she genuinely done to bring about a positive change in Muslim societies?

Yet, Brandeis University, a very prestigious University in America, has decided to aware her an 'honorary PhD' for her 'efforts' in helping Muslim women.
These days, all you need to get prestigious is be an ex-Muslim who bashes Islam. Fame, fortune, money AND fake PhD's will all be yours!

PLEASE sign a petition alerting officials at Brandeis how utterly ludicrous this award is:
http://www.change.org/petitions/brandeis-university-administration-speak-out-against-honoring-ayaan-hirsi-ali-at-brandeis-2014-commencement?share_id=EIwEbsedkV&utm_campaign=share_button_action_box&utm_medium=facebook&utm_source=share_petition

Christians having dreams and converting to Islam:
http://thefactsaboutislam.blogspot.co.uk/2014/03/christians-are-having-dreams-and.html

Invitation to Islam

Jesus taught people to do the Will of God (according to Mark 3:35) in order to become his brothers, mothers or sisters. A Muslim means one who submits to the Will of God. Do you want to become a brother/sister of Jesus? If yes, become a Muslim.

Learn about Islam:
http://www.thedeenshow.com
tags, Andrew c McCarthy, megyn Kelly, debate, mdi, muslim debate initiative, iera

Related:
Linda Sarsour Against Islamophobia

Friday, 4 April 2014

Muslim Response to Honor Diaries

Looks like it's silly season again. A film called Honor Diaries which is discussing the plight of Muslim women in Muslim countries is the topic on the tongues of a few Islamophobes. The topics discussed according to the film synopsis are; forced marriage, female circumcision (which the film makers call female genital mutilation), freedom of movement and education for women.

Interesting choice of subjects for a Western audience.

You just begin to think what in the world is the point of this movie whose executive director is a well known insulter of Islam and provocateur of Muslims, Ayaan Hirsi Ali? Looking to ratchet up the hatred of Muslims AGAIN? Preparing Western mindsets for another war against a Muslim nation AGAIN?

Nobody likes insincere and disingenuous propaganda campaigns against them or their community, right? I mean, the Christian West wouldn't like it if Al Jazeera or Press TV (Iranian TV channel) produced a constant stream of documentaries portraying all Western women as being the victims of pornography and sexual exploitation by big businesses? Western Christians wouldn't like it if these films also presented Western men as drug addicts, alcoholics, porn addicts etc? Or what about those high profile incidents of beastiality and incest in the West of late? Or what about the figure of over 20 million abortions having been performed in the US? Would Western Christians like it if Muslim TV channels began to use such as a propaganda tool to caricature Western Christian societies?

Don't get me wrong, there are issues in both the Muslim world and the Christian world that needs to be addressed. If the film makers of Honor Diaries had the clear intention of helping female victims of abuse in Muslim countries then they wouldn't be hiring a well known insulter of Islam and of Muslims as their executive producer.

Whatever happened to sincere dialogue, letter writing and lobbying of embassies? I guess none of that brings in cash, ratchets up hatred of Muslims and serves the right wing in general!

As for female education, of course Islam promotes the education of females. Don't conflate the practices of ignorant people or people who are unable to afford to send their female children to school as a religious command to prevent females from being educated:

The Importance of Girls’ Education in Islam

http://www.whyislam.org/social-values-in-islam/social-ties/the-importance-of-girls-education-in-islam/

As for forced marriage in Islam, here's Mufti Menk on the issue:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-ifxNYfcxw

As for honour killings, they are not Islamic as highlighted by Sheikh Ahmad Kutty:

“There is no such concept in Islam that is called “honor killing”. Islam holds every soul in high esteem and does not allow any transgression upon it. It does not allow people to take the law in their own hands and administer justice, because doing so will be leading to chaos and lawlessness. Therefore, based on this, Islam does not permit such killings.”

Christians having dreams and converting to Islam:
http://thefactsaboutislam.blogspot.co.uk/2014/03/christians-are-having-dreams-and.html

Invitation to Islam

Jesus taught people to do the Will of God (according to Mark 3:35) in order to become his brothers, mothers or sisters. A Muslim means one who submits to the Will of God. Do you want to become a brother/sister of Jesus? If yes, become a Muslim.

Learn about Islam:
http://www.thedeenshow.com
 
tags: noah, Jordan, honor killings muslim girls, father, daughter, boyfriend, girlfriend, fgm, cnn, honor diaries, cair, megyn Kelly, brooke Goldstein, Zionists, fox news, arabs, Iranians, London, Dearborn, Michigan, black, white,